Dear Dodgers: It’s Time to Sign Craig Kimbrel

The Dodgers’ 8-7 comeback win over the Arizona Diamondbacks on Sunday was euphoric in a special way, and feels like the kind that sets the tone for a special season. Cody Bellinger continued to show MVP potential, A.J. Pollock proved everyone (myself included) wrong yet again, and the offense showed versatility and relentlessness all around. The “emergency” rotation sans Hill and Kershaw has been elite, Walker Buehler’s rough first outing aside.

LOS ANGELES, CA – APRIL 01: Austin Barnes #15 looks on as manager Dave Roberts #30 pulls Joe Kelly #17 of the Los Angeles Dodgers in the seventh inning of the game against the San Francisco Giants at Dodger Stadium on April 1, 2019 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Jayne Kamin-Oncea/Getty Images)

However, we shouldn’t let the exhilarating comeback mask the circumstances that made it possible in the first place. I’m not talking about Buehler’s performance, which can be chalked up to the fact that this is basically his Spring Training. I am talking about the bullpen issues his brief start revealed when Pedro Baez came in and quickly surrendered the lead.

This of course comes after Joe Kelly blew two leads on Friday night, ultimately costing the team a four-game sweep against the Diamondbacks, and another 2-0 lead on Monday night against the Giants, where he took the loss.

Baez and Kelly are the veritable seventh/eighth inning options to build a bridge to Kenley Jansen, and while this is only four games out of 162, this is not an ideal start for those two.

More at Dodgers Nation

I, along with many others, have chastised the Dodgers owners and FO for their obsession with the luxury tax. So far, I am happily eating my crow as the offense is fine without Bryce Harper and the rotation is sound without Corey Kluber. But perhaps the best measure of their borderline excessive restraint is avoiding common sense bullpen moves. The first example was the offseason following the 2017 World Series, in which they let left-handed specialist Tony Watson (winner of two of the three games they won against Houston) leave for San Francisco, where he’s continued to flourish. (Granted, the decision to let Brandon Morrow walk, unpopular at the time, was vindicated.)

The Kelly signing this past offseason could be considered penance for that, but it’s still a bit of a gamble. Plus, it only draws more attention to the fact that his fellow 2018 champion Craig Kimbrel remains a free agent. It’s one thing to avoid a potential albatross of a contract, or a trade that could deplete the farm system. But when you have a porous bullpen fresh off an epic World Series game four meltdown, is looking iffy to start the year, and one of the best relievers of this era inexplicably is still on the market, it’s a no-brainer. The Dodgers, by every measure, must sign Craig Kimbrel ASAP.

The luxury tax is not an excuse to pass on Kimbrel, especially given the Dodgers brass offered Bryce Harper a record-setting AAV in their five-year proposal. The rationale of not giving relievers extended contracts is also irrelevant after the team shelled out three years and $25 million (plus incentives) to a Kelly whose regular season play has yet to match his October one.

Even if it’s early in the season, the bullpen still has question marks. Pedro Baez could very well be regressing to his pre-2018 form. Tony Cingrani, brilliant when healthy, is looking like damaged goods as his left shoulder injury from last season persists. Brock Stewart, already an odd man out before the season began, looks even more out of place after his performance so far. Kelly’s double meltdown that set up the longest regular season game in Dodger Stadium history is cause for concern.

The biggest conceivable issue is acquiring one elite closer when the team already has a highly paid one in Jansen. But the team has flirted with this scenario before back during the 2017 trade season, when Los Angeles was in talks with Baltimore to trade for another top closer, Zach Britton, to convert into a setup man for their World Series run. Furthermore, having another closer around could create good competition for Kenley as he seeks to bounce back from his difficult 2018 season.

But the true dealbreaker in whether or not Kimbrel should be signed is something many fans tend to forget: Jansen can opt out after this season. Even if he returns to his old form and notches the final out of a championship this year, the reality of him potentially leaving still looms. If that happens, and Kelly doesn’t dial it up enough to be trusted as a closer, L.A. could be in a difficult situation for 2020. For this year, some may argue that Kimbrel won’t accept anything but closing, but considering the inexcusable fact that he’s unsigned after Opening Day, he doesn’t have much of a choice at this point.

Finally, signing Kimbrel would be perfectly in step with the team’s philosophy since Andrew Friedman took the reins in 2014. That philosophy, as has been reiterated almost to the point of parody, is depth. Rather than go all-in on big acquisitions, the key instead is to be two-deep or more at every conceivable position. By giving themselves endless options, the team stays supple and competitive, weathering injuries and other adversities with an annual level of certitude most teams could only dream of. So why not have multiple elite closing options in the bullpen?

The 2019 Dodgers look thus far like a monstrously good team, and one that will only get better as the season goes on. The offense could end up being the best of both leagues. The rotation will get by, and come together once Buehler gets in a groove and Kershaw returns. But ignoring bullpen issues will only hurt them in the long run, chiefly when it counts in October. We don’t need another Marwin Gonzalez, Mitch Moreland or Steve Pearce moment to add to our gallery of pain.

Signing Kimbrel could very well make this a complete team on all fronts right from the get go. The money is there, and so is the urgent need for the present and possibly the future. It would be foolish to let this opportunity pass by.

Related Articles


  1. I believe Kimbrel is being pursued by Atlanta and Milwaukee and the discussion is “probable closer” and multi year contract. Sounds expensive, and we spent that dough on Kelley.

  2. I don’t think the FO would sign Kimbrel to an expensive long term deal. However a massive one year deal could benefit both sides.

  3. It’s gotta be tough constructing a pen. Kimbrel sounds great, but you even pointed out the Brandon Marrow example. FO got blasted for not resigning, but now it is clear it was right call. Had they thrown finicial constraint out the window and signed him for 2018, they would have been even more criticized for signing a pitcher they had broken down in the playoffs.

    Pen construction is a crapshoot. We unfortunately missed mark last year (and possibly this year). 2017, we had all the pieces to win it all. But when your Ace, your co-ace, your closer and your best offensive weapon all go cold at same time… What can you do? (All those players (sans Darvish) are STILL some of the highest paid players on the roster). Can you buy a championship? Doesn’t look like it… (Yes yes red Sox managed to do it, but is it anomoly or the norm?)

    1. Boston didn’t buy a championship. They bought the missing pieces in a championship team. A ace pitcher and 1 position player. I think that’s exactly what we were all hoping for all winter.Their position players are far superior to ours and much much younger. That’s how they built their team. A trade, draft and 1 free agent..Think their front office must also be superior.

      1. No doubt Dombrowski is superior. He’s in it to win it. Our guys are in it to win it only if it happens to work out if not no big deal it’s jusr a business and it’s already successful without a championship

      2. Exactly, poor fielding at first, Jansen poor pitching(He’s working on it), doesn’t mean we should give up on managements choices! Kimbrel is not the answer. What did I tell you about Caleb…. He’s coming around!

        1. I totally agree with the Dodgers need to supplement their bullpen, and Kimbrel is the best available. But, I don’t think he would want to go somewhere where he is the #2 guy and not racking up saves.

      3. Gordon, I think you’re correct, patience is needed! The team knows it’s a team sport but it takes a little lick at times….Tonight we got that

  4. Thanks for owning up to the Pollock/Harper situation. I was obviously all over posts here begging the FO to do what they did. So far it’s working out, but it’s way too early to be sure. 1 of my biggest knocks on Harper was his clubhouse attitude and that same concern continues with Kimbrel. I know that issue was a big part of why the Dodger’s didn’t truly pursue Harper and I wouldn’t be surprised if that keeps them from Kimbrel as well.

  5. The Dodgers could learn from the Yankees on how to construct a good bullpen. Like the Yankees, you have more money than g*d! Go get Kimbrel.
    Kelly may need more time but Baez and Stewart are retreads. How many costly home runs is it going to take to realize your mistakes? How many horrible losses are we going to have to watch?
    Oh yeah…….Drop Dead Giants!

  6. Judging from the way our BP is giving up leads and costing games, and the worth of the Dodgers, acquiring Kimbrel might be the prudent thing to do. I shudder when Baez or Kelly enter the game. Its a good thing we are blasting home runs; with our BP we will need to score as many runs as possible. Go Blue!!!

  7. Still baffled why the dodgers brass decided to release Josh Fields and his 2.20 ERA. Even after he cleared waivers they chose to release him from the organization rather then send him to the minors. They could really use him right about now.

    1. David, I agree. I liked Fields.I know it’s early but after tonite it would be a crime if the dodgers don’t sign Kimbrel. We will waste this teams full potential. Kelly blew both games otherwise we’d be 6-0. I’m sure somebody will right the ship but Dodger fans have waited long enough.
      Front office The verdicts in. Get Kimbrel NOW! Why let Milwaukee snag him or another contender. Monday night I said we need him. Tuesday’s game sealed the deal. The new owners coming in will have to live with the luxury tax penalty.

  8. Can’t wait till the pitching decisions are made! Personally to me it’s too early to jump ship!

  9. That’s tough. Kimbrel wants 6 years 100+ and he’s obviously not budging on that or he’d have been signed by now (not to mention he has a draft pick attached to him from the QO unless he waits till June). He had a rough August/Sept of last season and carried it over into October. Teams are shying away because of that end of year performance and the big money/years he’s asking. An arm like his would be awesome in the pen, but at what cost? Also, how long does he need to ramp up, 2 maybe 3 weeks? Hasn’t seen any action and didn’t have a spring. Again, I don’t disagree, just bringing some things to the conversation to ponder about. It would be interesting if they net him in some “typical Dodgers” way too haha
    Kelly is notoriously bad in April, not making excuses but not surprising how bad he’s been. Hoping he adjusts soon or it’s going to be Brandon League bad lol

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button