Dodgers: Five Keys to Winning it All This Postseason

The Dodgers are going on their 32nd year of trying to win a World Series. Over the last few years they’ve been so close. They were the best team in baseball in 2017 and we know what happened in that World Series. Since 2013 they’ve had a team that could win the World Series but they have not gotten over that hump.

There have been various reasons for that and some of those reasons are addressed in this article. Here are some keys and specific points that the Dodgers need to deal with to raise the Commissioner’s Trophy in November.

That Key Base Hit

How many times have the Dodgers been in a postseason game where one base hit (or even a sacrifice fly) could have made the difference in a series? In my mind, the Dodgers had so many scoring opportunities in the 2017 World Series (games 2 and 7 specifically) that even with the rampant cheating they could have won. Looking back at the 2019 loss to the Nationals, there were so many missed opportunities, especially game 5. Instead, key strikeouts or ground outs to the right side of the infield have dominated those situations.

One common complaint is that there is a lack of a two-strike approach for the Dodgers. They seem to be swinging for the fences (they DO hit a lot of home runs) when all they need is to put the ball in play. After the Wild Card Series, they will play all their games in the new ballpark for the Texas Rangers, which is not a great place for home runs. Those home runs we have seen at Dodger Stadium that barely clear the fence are outs in Texas.

Getting hits into the gaps might be one of the biggest keys for whichever teams end up winning.

One other item that could help in this area would be a dose of small ball. With the extreme shifts, I wouldn’t mind seeing a bunt every once in a while. The Dodgers do have some capable base stealers like Mookie Betts, Chris Taylor, and Cody Bellinger. AJ Pollock and Austin Barnes could be threats also. Maybe hit and run with some of the better contact hitters like Justin Turner, Mookie Betts and Will Smith and take advantage of certain situations.

The Dodgers have some players on offense like Cody Bellinger, Corey Seager and AJ Pollock that have all performed well below their capabilities in the playoffs. I hope they can stay within themselves and change their playoff legacies. If those three can step it up in the playoffs then it could mean a lot more success.

Learning From History

This section is geared towards management. We’ve seen the Dodgers seemingly make the same mistakes over and over. Sometimes it seems the management staff seems to overthink and then there are times where logic seems to be ignored. Some of the key items that I’d not like to see happen again:

  • Putting players into a game whether as a starter or as a substitute when another player should be in. One example I cannot forget was when the Dodgers started Chase Utley over Logan Forsythe in game 2 of the 2017 World Series. Forsythe had been playing well in September and throughout the playoffs and was a superior defensive player. The first run the Astros got in that game was started when Josh Reddick hit a ball to the left of Utley that he could not stop. Forsythe would have had a better shot that. Utley also hadn’t had a postseason hit in almost 20 at-bats and was 38 years old and overmatched. The Dodgers put an inferior player in the lineup, and they paid for it.
  • Managing the bullpen is my biggest issue. Bringing in Brandon Morrow in the 2017 World Series game 3 when the team is down by three early in the game had ramifications in game five when Morrow was toast. Not using other assets early in the game was costly also for game five. The telegraphing of Kenley Jansen was to go for six outs in the 2018 World Series was beyond silly, especially since he was degraded. They did the same with Clayton Kershaw in the 2019 NLCS game five. Pulling Rich Hill in the 2018 World Series? Using Ryan Madson continually in the 2018 World Series when he was proving that he wasn’t right. The list of pitching management mistakes over the last four postseasons is extensive. I think they actually made the fewest mistakes in 2016. It blows my mind how many bad pitching decisions have been made in the playoffs since they started their playoff run in 2013.
  • Some of the lineups in the playoffs have been interesting. They seem to rely too much on the pitching matchups. One of the side effects of that is some poor defensive alignments. I am hopeful that the team they have now has enough players that should not be platooned so the lineup should be balanced between offense and defense.
  • When the Dodgers start pulling out their starters too early for pinch hitters they have run out of players and have to live with what is left. I don’t want to see so many substitutions that when the game heads to the ninth the Dodgers are out of options. Remember Andre Ethier in left field in the bottom of the 10th in 2017’s World Series game 5? My great fear is that the tying run is on third base in the ninth inning with a nasty left-hander on the mound and there is nobody available to pinch hit for Joc Pederson. Thankfully, the DH could or should rectify some of these issues.
  • All other relief pitchers seem to have a short leash except the closer. If Kenley Jansen is struggling in his warmups, don’t bring him in. If he starts off with not hitting his location then get another reliever up and ready.
  • It is obvious that management wants to repair the playoff legacies of players like Clayton Kershaw and Kenley Jansen. The best thing that can be done for them is understanding what they can do now instead of how good they were in the past. Use them as they could best help the team. The legacy they need is to raise the World Series trophy, not excel individually.

The Hot Hand

If a player is in an awful slump, they do not have to bat fourth, even if they have done it all year. Move them down in the lineup or move them to the bench. It’s a strength that Dodgers’ management has faith in their players, but is it worth losing in the playoffs? If a reliever has been bad, then stop using them in crucial situations. Going back to the Utley story above, don’t play someone who is not capable when another player is hot.

Sometimes I think the Dodgers would rather lose with “their guys” than win with a fresh face.

Play the Kids

Speaking of fresh faces, the Dodgers need to play the kids. If a veteran is not doing the job, then go to one of the kids. I hope they don’t hesitate to put Justin Turner at DH in some games and start Edwin Rios at third. JTs bat is invaluable, but his defense has been fading. If a team decides to start bunting with JT at third it almost becomes an automatic hit. They should not hesitate to pitch Victor Gonzalez over someone like Alex Wood. It has been great to see rookie starting pitchers Tony Gonsolin and Dustin May earn regular turns in the rotation. I hope that continues. Brusdar Graterol has done well and he should get a chance at some tough innings.

One Last Chance

After the 2020 season, there are several Dodgers who’ve played major roles on the team becoming free agents. For those guys there may not even be another chance to win a World Series. This could add extra pressure to those players. The soon-to-be free agents are:

After 2021, the contracts of Clayton Kershaw, Kenley Jansen, and Corey Seager expire. It would be horrible for this group to not get a World Series championship, especially after getting robbed in 2017. Let’s hope they and the rest of the team can play within themselves.


For the third time in four years, I truly believe the Dodgers have the best team in baseball. It seems the only thing that can stop them is themselves. No team has the 1 through 28 roster depth. The Dodgers might be batting Chris Taylor or AJ Pollock in the nine spot. How many teams are that good? So many of these players have a lot of post-season experience. Sometimes it takes a few failures to finally break through and I think this is the year.

NEXT: Edwin Ríos is Earning Himself a Prominent Role in October

Tim Rogers

A fan of the Dodgers since 1973 since I got my first baseball cards while living in Long Beach. I came to San Diego for college and never left nor did I ever switch my Dodgers' allegiance. Some know me as the "sweater guy". #ProspectHugger


  1. It’s interesting because the big issue in 2018 (when the Dodgers were not the best team) was the incessant platooning which also disregarded who was actually playing the best in order to play the person the numbers said should be playing. We seem to have finally gotten past that idiocy. It does seem like the sudden “launching pad” that Chavez Ravine has become has taken away from the Dodgers’ ability to manufacture runs – an important playoff consideration. But with Betts setting the table I am less worried about that. During the Dodgers one series in Texas this season, they hit some balls out, so maybe that isn’t as much of a concern.

  2. Well an intelligent article from dodger nation. I may start reading the articles again. Normally they are written by the dodger pr department. Good article tim. Good analysis but the dodgers will be mad.

    1. Yes a very solid article and these things needed to be said. They should stop flooding the site with Brook and Clints spins and speak more truth

  3. Tim thank you for your article. I agree with 100%. I believe the Dodgers have had the best team 3 out of the last 5 years. I also believe that Roberts has been the reason they have lost.
    His platooning and especially his pitching choices have been the reason for the losses.

    I do not believe the Dodgers will ever win a World Series with Roberts as the manager. When you are deep in the playoffs the opponent has parity in regards to talent. It’s a manager’s decisions that are the key to winning. Roberts is too concerned with being a friend than a manager he makes the best decision instead of the popular one.


  5. As a Dodgers fan, yes. You got this right. Doc needs to start making the “tough” decisions and quit worrying about coaxing the veterans’ egos. If someone isn’t playing well, then next man up. And he hasn’t done that with Kenley Jansen and honestly, that worries me. We have so many live arms in the pen that can close and he keeps putting him out there. We’re our own worst enemy, not any other team.

  6. Tim, I am also 100% in agreement with all issues covered here.I also concur with Tmaxter about Roberts and reasons why perhaps Dodgers won’t win a WS with him as manager. A perfect example is his decisions in regards to the pitching in Game 5 of the 2019 NLDS,where he adamantly said he would make those very same decisions all over again. But if the pitching once again can’t keep the ball in the yard and the offense strikes out a lot especially with RISP another team will hoist that WS Trophy in October.

  7. In discussing past performance in the post-season, it is always so easy to talk about what you would have done differently, particularly when a player does not get the job done. Managers put in pitchers who potentially match up best with the next 2-3 batters. It does not always work successfully, but that does not make it a bad decision. Fortunately for the Dodgers this year, there are multiple options. You will not have a situation where Jansen needs to pitch 2 innings, or Kershaw has to be used in relief.

    1. Kershaw didn’t need to be used last year either. The Dodgers had the entire bullpen to get the last 6 outs. The Nats were dead and Friedman and Roberts revived them

    2. your last setence is right on. Roberts has Abslotely NO reason in the whole wide world to ask Kenley for a 6 out save and CK IS A STARTR has been his whole career. And does NOT need to be seen in relief in any late inning situation. But again. It’s Roberts and his managing of the staff in October that wakes me up in the middle of the night.

  8. Top 5 reasons why Dodgers will win the WS.
    Mookie Betts
    Justin Turner
    Walker Buehler
    Dustin May
    Joc Peterson

    Top 5 reasons Dodgers won’t win the WS.
    Cody Bellinger
    Kenley Jansen
    Doc Roberts
    Pedro Baez

    1. Tim , that 2nd column, is accurate but this would my order of those 5 reasons Dodgers won’t win a WS:

      Kenley Jansen
      Cody Bellinger
      Clayton Kershaw
      Pedro Baez

  9. Why they won’t win:
    1. Execs interfering.
    2. Computer nerds making substitutions.
    3. Roberts out-smarting himself.
    4. Roberts out-smarting himself again.
    5. Roberts out-smarting himself one more time.

    1. Glad someone else besides me mentioned the fact that the FO interferes with on field decision making. All I see online are thousands of comments blaming Roberts only for our yearly fiascos.

  10. This is the best article I have ever seen Dodger Nation.

    Thank you for pointing out the need for small ball, and creating opportunities. Betts was such a great addition. He creates runs from the leadoff spot. He can create a single, or force an error on weak grounders, as well as knocking it over the fence. He steals bases. He takes extra bases. He sets a great tone for others to do the same. His old school take anything you can get approach is a winning approach.

    You are right about Jansen. Don’t put him in if there are better options. If you do put him in, you have to be willing to pull him, just like any other releiver, if he is not effective. I don’t know if I’ve ever seen Roberts pull Jansen after putting him in.

    You’re right about going with the young guys who have proven themselves. May and Gonsolin have earned their shots. They have handled the pressure, and delivered. They will contribute to a championship if they are given a chance. You can’t leave weapons like this on the bench and expect to maintain the same high level of success into the postseason.

    This article demonstrates common sense, which is actually extremely uncommon these days. It is far from the usual Dodger Nation cheerleading fluff piece. It’s not negative. It’s real. I sincerely hope that Dave Roberts reads it.

  11. The Dodgers aren’t just the best team in baseball this year. This is the best Dodger team I have ever seen. They are better than the 1981 team, and far better team than the 1988 team. In fact, this is one of the best teams I have ever seen. Now they just have seal the deal. Even Dave Roberts will have a hard time screwing things up this time. But don’t underestimate him.

  12. Trying to help Dave Roberts stop his inept management of pitchers and taking hot players out of the lineup I suggest that Tony Gonsolin’s versatility as other than as a pitcher should put him on the roster the entire post season. From his sophomore through senior seasons in college plus a collegiate summer league he has about 600+ at bats and a .308+/- BA plus other good offensive stats. In college Tony was only a spot starter and reliever – he played mostly in right field (sorry Adam Kolarek). That makes him valuable as an extra inning pinch hitter and experienced role player.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Back to top button