Dodgers Team News

Dodgers: Pros and Cons to Jacob deGrom and Justin Verlander

Two of the biggest pitchers on the free-agent market are Jacob deGrom, a two-time Cy Young Award winner who has spent his entire career with the Mets, and Justin Verlander, who has won three Cy Young Awards with the Tigers and Astros. The Dodgers are in the market for a starting pitcher or two and have a lot of money, so naturally they’ve been linked to both stars.

There’s a case to be made for and against each of these two superstars, which we’ll cover shortly. But first, we put it to a vote among Dodger fans, and the results have been overwhelming thus far. Nearly three-quarters of you would rather have L.A. sign deGrom than Verlander.

Like I said, there are pros and cons to both. Let’s look at them:

Jacob deGrom

Pro: When he’s healthy, he’s the best pitcher in baseball. He has a 2.05 ERA over the last five seasons.

Con: He hasn’t been very healthy the last two years, making just 26 starts over 2021-22 combined.

Con: He rejected the Mets’ qualifying offer, meaning the Dodgers would lose their second and fifth picks in next year’s draft (which would be their second-round pick and the compensation pick they received because Tyler Anderson signed with the Angels) and they’d lose $1 million from their international bonus pool.

Pro: If someone offered to trade you Jacob deGrom in exchange for Tyler Anderson, your second-round pick, and $1 million in international bonus money, you’d probably jump at that deal.

Con: He’s going to demand a lot of money per year.

Pro: It likely won’t be for too many years, considering his age and injury history.

Justin Verlander

Pro: When he’s healthy, he’s one of the best pitchers in baseball. He posted a 1.75 ERA in 2022 to win his third Cy Young Award.

Con: He missed basically all of 2020 and 2021 with Tommy John surgery, which can make a team nervous.

Con: Oh yeah, and he turns 40 in February.

Con: Did we mention that he played for the 2017 Astros who cheated to steal a World Series title from the Dodgers?

Pro: He’s a pitcher, and it was the hitters who cheated, and they were well into the cheating scheme long before he was acquired in August of that year.

Con: He’s also going to demand a lot of money per year.

Pro: His deal might be even shorter than deGrom’s, considering that he’s starting to get unsolicited AARP catalogs in his mailbox.

As you can see, there are pros and cons to both pitchers. But it appears the fans have spoken, and they want deGrom.

Have you subscribed to our YouTube Channel yet? Subscribe and hit that notification bell to stay up to date on all the latest Dodgers news, rumors, interviews, live streams, and more!

Jeff Snider

Jeff was born into a Dodgers family in Southern California and is now raising a Dodgers family of his own in Utah. During his previous career as an executive at a technology company, he began writing about baseball in his spare time. After leaving corporate America in 2014, he started doing it professionally. Jeff wrote and edited for Baseball Essential for years before joining Dodgers Nation. He's also the co-host of the Locked On Dodgers podcast, a daily podcast that brings the smart fan's perspective on our Boys in Blue. Jeff has a degree in English from Brigham Young University. Favorite Player: Clayton Kershaw Favorite Moment: Kirk Gibson's homer will always have a place, but Kershaw's homer on Opening Day 2013 might be the winner.


  1. Two senior citizen starters, one of these guys and Kershaw WILL strain the rest of available pitching resources. Not offering a 3 year deal at 40 mill to TA was a big mistake, his chances of 3 solid years is much better than either of these two and less than half the price.

  2. Leave them be. Trade for Burnes and Adames and extend Burnes. Then go get a bad ass closer. Done.

  3. I am not entirely optimistic about LA’s minor league pitcher prospects. There is some quality there, but not that elite. Thus, for LA to be successful in the long term, they should sign someone younger with a lot of upside–via trade.

  4. Rodon is more likely to pitch full seasons with good quality (not as good as deGrom, if deGrom pitches). It is not smart to pay 20%+ of your payroll to a pitcher. Losing Tyler Anderson makes no sense.The current rotation is 1.Urias 2. Kershaw 3 Gonsolin 4. Dustin May 5. open 6. Pepiot 7. Grove 8. Andre Jackson 9. Bobby Miller 10. Gavin Stone 11. Emett Sheehan. Need that 5th starter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button