Assessing the Dodgers Path to an 8th Consecutive NL West Crown

In less than 90 days, the Los Angeles Dodgers will begin their quest for an eighth consecutive division title. Even including 2016 and 2018, when the Dodgers took the NL West title by the skin of their teeth, they have won the division by an average of almost 9 games. There isn’t another team in the league that can boast that dominant of a run.

Will the competition be stiffer in 2020?

Who Got Better?

Arizona Diamondbacks

  • 2019 Record: 85-77
  • ERA: 12th in MLB (4.25)
  • Runs Scored: 11th in MLB (813)

The Diamondbacks finished four games out of the NL Wildcard last year as a team that was good in many departments, but not great in any one. After trading away Zach Greinke to the Astros this past July, they went out and signed bonafide ace Madison Bumgarner. Bumgarner should re-solidify the top of the rotation along with Robbie Ray and the up-and-coming Zach Gallen (2.89 ERA in 8 starts). There’s a lot of tread on the MadBum tires, but he’s still a pitcher no one wants to face in the fall.

They’ll open the year with a better closer in Archie Bradley. In addition to being a big Dave Roberts supporter, Bradley posted 17 saves and a 1.71 ERA in the second half. Adding the 34 year-old Junior Guerra will also improve the back of the bullpen. Expect Arizona to win more close games.

Led by Eduardo Escobar and Ketel Marte, Arizona has a legitimate lineup that will continue to churn out runs. Bringing in Kole Calhoun will give them a second power bat in the outfield as opposed to a fading Adam Jones.

Breakout Christian Walker filled the Goldschmidt void admirably in 2019 (.259/.348/.476) and 2017 All-Star third baseman Jake Lamb just needs to stay healthy. Throw in homerun hitting catcher Carson Kelly and two-time Gold Glove shortstop Nick Ahmed, and Arizona might have one of the best infields in the NL.

[adace-ad id=”117991″]

Who Stayed the Same?

Colorado Rockies

  • 2019 Record: 71-91
  • ERA: 25th in MLB (5.17)
  • Runs Scored: 9thth in MLB (835)

At this juncture, the Rockies haven’t dealt either of their high paid All-Stars in Nolan Arenado and Charlie Blackmon. There’s been plenty of offseason chatter that the Rockies are open to dealing one or both if the price is right. Will the trade rumors further frustrate a locker room that massively underperformed in 2019 a year after pushing the Dodgers to game 163?

Outfielder David Dahl (.302/.353/.524) will be back following a scary leg injury in August and adds depth to a lineup that also features shortstop Trevor Story (.917 OPS) and savvy vet/Dodger killer Daniel Murphy. Getting runs across shouldn’t be the challenge.

Stop me if you’ve heard this before, but the Rockies pitching staff is a concern. Backing up the porous starting rotation, that had the worst ERA in baseball, was the third worst bullpen. In 2019, the Rockies had four starters make at least 15 starts who finished with ERAs north of 6.56. 2018 Cy Young candidate Kyle Freeland was one of those four and figures to be better this upcoming season along with German Marquez…or it will get worse because it’s Coors Field. Pour one out for Wade Davis (8.65 ERA & 1.875 WHIP).

San Francisco Giants

  • 2019 Record: 77-85
  • ERA: 15th in MLB (4.38)
  • Runs Scored: 28th in MLB (678)

Year 1 A.B. (After Bochy). Another year where the Giants will inject more youth, hope to shed pricey veterans, and bolster the farm in the process. This is the final year of their annual $19.8M donation to the Jeff Samardzija foundation. It could also be the year Farhan Zaidi finds a taker for first baseman Brandon Belt who never lived up to his $68.8M contract. Zaidi was given a difficult rebuilding task, but a 19-6 July offered a glimpse at a return to winning baseball in the Bay.

For the first time in a long time, the Giants have two top-100 prospects in catcher Joey Bart and outfielder Heliot Ramos. Bart’s promotion to the bigs plays a pivotal role in rejuvenating Buster Posey’s sagging offensive production by allowing him to spend time at first.

More than just a name, outfielder Mike Yastrzemski (.852 OPS) was a huge factor and gave the Giants something they’re always missing – power. The Zach Cozart trade and Kevin Gausman signing were smart, low risk maneuvers. Who knows, maybe starter Johnny Cueto returns to form in the pitching friendly confines of Oracle Park.

The Giants are still at least a year away from challenging for the division title.

Who Got Worse?

San Diego Padres

  • 2019 Record: 70-92
  • ERA: 18th in MLB (4.60)
  • Runs Scored: 27th in MLB (682)

In 2019, the Padres had the best closer in baseball, one of the best shortstops, Manny Machado, Eric Hosmer…and that was about it. Tatis Jr., Machado, and Hosmer were not enough to carry a lineup that was third in strikeouts and in the bottom third of the league in walks. Trading homerun hitting outfielder Hunter Renfroe to the Rays for Tommy Pham gives San Diego a much better contact hitter who steals bases (25 in 2019) too.

Starter Chris Paddack (3.33 ERA in 140.2 IP) showed top of the rotation potential, but can new additions Zach Davies and Garrett Richards give a young, patchwork staff stability? When you have a closer as good as Yates, it’s all about the bridge which explains the aggressive signing of Drew Pomeranz ($34M/4 years). 

Much like 2019, the Padres will be entertaining, but probably not successful.

Did the Dodgers Get Worse?

  • 2019 Record: 106-56
  • ERA: 4th in MLB (3.78)
  • Runs Scored: 5th in MLB (886)

For the pessimists, losing an ERA-title winner like Hyun-Jin Ryu rarely improves a pitching staff. Once again, the Dodgers are betting on their depth bailing them out of spending on free agents. The front office was unwilling to pay top dollar to retain a pitcher they groomed into an All-Star and Cy Young candidate. First baseman, elder statesman, and clubhouse favorite David Freese retired this October and left the Dodgers devoid of a clutch pinch-hit playoff bat.

Clayton Kershaw is a year older after registering his first ERA over 3.00 since 2008 and again, struggled in the playoffs.

On the flip side, number two overall prospect Gavin Lux will get plenty of at-bats in 2020 and could be a superstar in the making. Fireballers Tony Gonsolin and Dustin May return one year wiser after their first taste of the senior circuit. Newly signed reliever and certified Friedman reclamation project Blake Treinen provides insurance in case Kenley Jansen continues to decline. Outfielder AJ Polluck was never able to get into a rhythm after playing just 86 games due to injury.

Better or worse than 2019, it would be an absolute shock if the Dodgers didn’t win the NL West again in 2020. 

Dodgers: Trade or No Trade, They’ll Be Good

Eric Eulau

Born and raised in Ventura, not "Ven-CH-ura", California. Favorite Dodger Stadium food is the old school chocolate malt with the wooden spoon. Host of the Dodgers Nation 3 Up, 3 Down Podcast.


  1. I’m looking forward to Spring Training this year. Do any of you have suggestions on how to get the most of my trip to Camelback?
    I went once before and just saw players come out, warm up, take some no and leave. I’d like to know how to watch them doing drills, training etc.
    My best up close experience was watching a minor league game where I say next to the dugout and talked to the players during the game.

    1. Remember when the Braves won consecutive division titles from 1996 to 2005 with zero world championships. Maybe the current Dodgers are the reincarnation of that Braves team.

  2. Despite the loss of Ryu and not acquiring an “impact player” as Friedman promised, or any player of note, they should still win this mediocre division which is their sole purpose. Once the elite teams are confronted in the playoffs however, unless they are very fortunate and the ball bounces their way, they’ll be eliminated for the eighth straight year. And of course the likelihood of Roberts making a bone-headed move to lose a game or series is almost assured. On the bright side, we will be THE crowning example when folks speak about play-off futility! Atlanta and the Buffalo Bills forgotten…actually, we might be wearing that crown now.

  3. They are clearly worse. Maybe Lux can save that statement. And maybe 2 of the group Urias, May, Tony G can help as well. They need to give Rios a real shot and quit messing with Kiki and Taylor. Beaty as well.

  4. Who Knows Nik, maybe Friedman is banking that Sherzer, Strasberg, maybe Freddy Freeman Will Smith all sustain season ending injuries , and our Triple A guys can get through Soto Eaton Corbin possibly! I mean anything is possible!! Even though Friedman didn’t believe in May or Gonsolin last Oct when we needed them most and instead started a 39 year old injured Hill , Friedman must have seen something in them while he was watching the N.L.C.S, N.L.D.S, both ALSeries, and then the World series that changed his mind. As now they won’t have to worry about top tier line ups!! Back to the N.L. west comfort zone!

  5. I am more concerned with winning a WS championship than an 8th consecutive NL West crown. Been there, done that. Anything less would be a waste. Go Blue!!!!!

    1. HAPPY NEW YEAR BLUE LOU!!!!!!!!!
      I am concerned more with winning a WS Championship as well, but IMHO this team is not better but for now have taken a step back and not as good as last year. mainly it’s because of the very limited response to that game 5 bouncing during this off season being reason why. Still too LH hitter heavy and 3 potential starters that will have inning limits as i understand it that won’t be available in October. But October is not guaranteed anyway.

    2. Without another proven starting pitcher, this upcoming Dodger team looks weaker than any of their teams over the last three years. They will win the division by default, and make an early exit. Pitching wins in the postseason. Even with the addition of Treinen, the bullpen remains questionable as well, especially as rookies like May, Gonsolin, and Urias become less available as they transition to starter roles.

  6. Urias, May, Gonsolin and Strip will compete for 2 starting spots! trade Joc and a few other minor pieces for a righty hitter and we are good to go!

  7. The thing is, I don’t care if the Dodgers win their 8th division title in a row. The division winner avoids the one-game playoff that Wild Card teams have to deal with, but other than that it’s meaningless to me and probably most other Dodger fans as well.

    The Dodgers will have to suffer a large number of injuries and or down year performances by a several important players to give another team a chance to the West in 2020, but assuming that doesn’t happen and the Dodgers win their division again in 2020, that doesn’t get them one inch closer to getting to and winning the World Series.

    1. Most of us want the World Series but there’s a strange group of people who have literally admitted that they only care about the regular season because it gives them nightly enjoyment and are under the false belief that the playoffs are dumb luck and give no credit at all to the guys that went out and got it done.

  8. Dodgers want to make money, not win Championships.
    They could have built an amazing team with the players that were available. Dodgers wouldn’t spend the money.
    Dave Roberts needs to be a coach not manager

    1. I am 71 years young and I was/used to be a life-long Dodger fan. However it does not matter how many games they win during the regular season, as long as Dave Roberts (DR) is their manager – they will NEVER win the World Series. After DR blows the previous two chances to be World Champions with his typical mismanaging of the pitching staff/bullpen/Kershaw and by never learning from his mistakes, he purposely/strategically uses Kershaw in relief yet again to make it 3 blown championships in a row. I’m sorry, but I believe in baseball that THREE strikes you’re out – DR should have been FIRED…plain and simple!!!

  9. About Buehler, my prediction is that Buehler will be on the IR list for a good part of the 2020 campaign. The Dodgers not only need another strong right-handed pitcher, they need to improve the infield by establishing a day in day out orderly fashion as to who plays where.

  10. Since Friedman has taken over there’s always been a prospect or two that have really showed up and contributed in meaningful ways. Given the recent history of the Dodgers I hope that someone, maybe even one of the guys mentioned in the article, will become big time contributors. I think this season more than ever our ability to convert prospects into players will have an impact on the season.

    On a second note, how much of the Dodgers NL West titles are based in our success and how much of the our success is based in the fact that some of the other NL West teams are not the most competitive?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button