Dodgers Team News

Dodgers: Among First Base Options, Roberts Lists Billy McKinney for Some Reason

Is this a threat, Dave? In his pre wild card media availability on Tuesday, Dodgers manager Dave Roberts was understandably asked about who could or would fill in for the injured Max Muncy at first base. The expected names were listed… Matt Beaty, Cody Bellinger, Albert Pujols. Then he said Billy McKinney.

Yeah, I know, right?

McKinney has been on the injured list since early September, dealing with a hip impingement. The outfielder went out on a rehab assignment with Triple-A Oklahoma City last week before the end of the minor league season. He went 4-15 (.267) in 4 games. But in 37 games with the big league Dodgers, he collected just 12 hits in 82 at-bats (.146) — hardly numbers that are worthy of seeing time in an elimination game.

“We’ve got some options, but I’m going to think about it for another 24 hours, Dave said on Tuesday. “If a guy starts a game, he may not finish the game there, trying to keep some optionality with the lineup, with the defense, all that stuff.”

Related: Trea Turner is Not Scared of a Do-or-Die Wild Card Game

Dave cited defense as a big factor in his eventual decision for who will start tonight at Dodger Stadium. With Max Scherzer as a heavy fly ball pitcher, it’s fair to assume that Cody Bellinger will be the starting centerfielder. Notably, Roberts did seem to make it seem like he’s less sold on Gavin Lux’s outfield defense. At any rate, between Beaty and Pujols at first, Beaty’s defensive numbers have been better this year, albeit in short work.

Beaty, Pujols, and Bellinger all were seen getting work at 1B on the field during Tuesday’s practice day. McKinney was not. So, by all accounts, chances are that he’s not a true option at first base, at least as a starter. But there is a reasonable shot that he will be on the active roster later this afternoon. With Clayton Kershaw injured and off the roster, as well as Max Muncy, plus Walker Buehler expected to be off the roster on Wednesday (he would start Friday’s NLDS game 1), there’s definitely room for Billy McKinney. It just will make most Dodgers fans feel better to not hear him listed as a potential replacement for Muncy.

Please, Dave.

NEXT: Trea Turner is Not Scared of a Do-or-Die Wild Card Game

Clint Pasillas

Clint is the lead editor and manager of, and a host and analyst on DN's Blue Heaven podcast live stream. Since joining Dodgers Nation, Clint has helped grow the site into a top-50 baseball website in the world. He's been writing, blogging, and podcasting Dodgers since about 2008. He was there for Nomar, Greg Maddux, and Blake DeWitt, and he'll be there for Walker Buehler, Alex Verdugo, Dustin May, and any Dodgers of the future. He's also a sandwich enthusiast, a consummate athlete, and a friend.


  1. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE not Mckinney!! And some wonder why they Roberts is inept at in game and roster management. By NO means under the sun does McKinney even deserve a roster spot for this do or die game. If McKinney is on the roster for this game Roberts needs to see a doctor and fast!

  2. Beaty or Bellinger on first base for defense and athleticism. Pujols is too cozy with his former buddies with the Cards…he can pinch hit vs lefties.

  3. Billy Mickeymouse on the roster. Well, we all know he will come around if Doc gives him enough a bats (say 10,000). But lil league Doc wants everyone to feel good. Win or lose. He sees the game as a warm up for next year. Doing the same thing that cost us the pennant. Playing guys to “provide depth” and experience. A lollipop to everyone win or lose! A pat on the back and a good ole “we’ll get them next year”.

  4. C’mon! Enough with the “everybody gets a trophy” approach. After the season, Roberts needs to go.

    The Dodgers can right a 22-year wrong and bring back Mike Scioscia!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Back to top button