Dodgers: Max Scherzer Blames LA for Dead Arm, The Truth About His Usage

Despite the Dodgers’ best efforts to re-sign Max Scherzer, LA’s key deadline acquisition is heading back to the NL East after it was announced that he would be joining the New York Mets.

Scherzer, who posted a sparkling 1.98 ERA in 11 regular season starts with the Dodgers, was officially introduced as a member of the New York Mets through a Zoom press conference on Wednesday. Accompanied by super-agent, Scott Boras, Mets General Manager Billy Eppler and team owner Steven Cohen, the 3-time Cy Young Award winner discussed what led him to sign with the Mets on a three-year, $130 million deal that set a new Major League Baseball record for highest annual average at $43.3M per season. Scherzer cited the Mets proximity to his home in Jupiter Florida and how returning to the east coast would make life easier for his family, as a significant factor in his decision to take his talents to Queens.

The future Hall of Famer donned the blue and orange New York Mets hat for the first time and exuded the positivity and excitement that is typical at introductory press conferences for marquee free agents, but he did offer some revealing comments about his time in LA, when he was asked about the ‘dead arm’ he experienced that forced him to miss Game 6 of the NLCS.

Scherzer said that the Dodgers watching his pitch count lowered his ‘work capacity’ and that ultimately, he was ‘compromised’ as a result and was unable to perform the way he did during the 2019 postseason when he helped lead the Nationals to a World Series Championship. Scherzer averaged 94 pitches per start after being dealt to the Dodgers at the deadline, compared to the 103 pitches he threw per start with the Nationals in 2019. However, Scherzer was forced to exit prematurely in 2 of his 11 starts down the stretch. One due to a rain delay in early August against the Phillies where he went just 3.1 IP and tossed just 58 pitches and another due to suffering a tight hamstring against the Braves in early September, where he went 6 IP and threw 76 pitches and could have easily gone another one or two frames. Additionally, despite back-to-back subpar starts to end the regular season, Scherzer was able to throw 102 pitches against the Rockies in Colorado, where he allowed five earned runs in 5 IP and then against San Diego where he tossed 97 pitches and gave up 5 earned runs in 5.1 IP. So, while his pitch count was slightly lower, he was given a much longer leash than most Dodgers pitchers typically enjoy.

Moreover, in 2019, Scherzer made 12 of his 27 starts on four days of rest, (44%) with 15 of his 27 starts coming on five or more days rest. In his eleven starts with the Dodgers, four of his eleven starts coming on four days of rest (36%). So, while the numbers do bear out Scherzer’s claims that he was used differently with the Dodgers than the Nationals, it’s tough to say if higher pitch counts and more starts on four days rest with LA would have led to a more stretched out Scherzer that would have been at less risk of experiencing dead arm. We discuss if Max Scherzer’s reduced pitch count and pitching on longer rest with the Dodgers are what led to him being unavailable in Game 6 of the NLCS. Plus, we discuss other relevant factors that could have led to Scherzer running out of gas, like his advanced age, pitching in a contract year, being the thick of a Cy Young race and more!

Max Scherzer Blames Dodgers for Dead Arm, Did LA Mishandle Max? Truth About Max’s Dead Arm in LA

Have you subscribed to our YouTube Channel yet? Subscribe and hit that notification bell to stay up to date on all the latest Dodgers news, rumors, interviews, live streams, and more!

NEXT: Corey Seager Revealed He’s Recruiting Clayton Kershaw to Texas

Doug McKain

Doug McKain is a lifelong Dodger fan and hosts Dodgers Nation’s “DNpostgame” show online. He also hosts Dodgers DougOut and the LA Sports Report on YouTube. DMAC is also a rabid Lakers fan, and lover of all Los Angeles sports.


  1. SEE! Now Max is coming about on he was “used” and how that contributed to his decision to move on. That is what eye waz thinking on team player decisions all year long. Oh well….and next year?

  2. Lot of mileage on that arm, we’ll see what the Mets get out of him for that 120M in his upper 30s. Wouldn’t be surprised if that amazing 2 month stretch for the Dodgers, in a contract push, didn’t suck some life out of what he’s going to be able to do moving forward.

  3. Not for a collidge gradiate! The torture is finding out I was wright all last year on the line-up choices being made for my Dodgers!

  4. cannot go down as a gibson drysdale or koufax his arm hurts koufax woulda been worth 43mil

  5. Max is full of crap actually. He blames the Dodgers for “under-utilizing” him which caused his arm to degrade to dead arm. But hasn’t it always been the opposite – the more an arm is used the more opportunity to injure it or get “dead arm”? Which is it Maxy? By that logic, he should have thrown 15 pitches every game he started for the Dodgers. I think he pitched his ass-off on the Dodgers in his contract year to MAXimize the new contract value, playoffs be damned. Congratulations, mission accomplished.

  6. Do you guys really think pitching 5-10 less pitches per start made any difference? Does potching less lead to a dead arm or pitching more? It sounds like BS to me, jusf Max trying to explain away his arm being sore. I wanted to see him do good, but not anymore. His arm might not many bullets left, poor Mets!

  7. Mad Max gave a very poor excuse for his dead arm in NLCS not staring game 6.
    However ,I don’t blame him to sign with the Mets for 130 millions USD 3years deal
    Good luck Mets for having overpaid Mad Max

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button