Dodgers News: MLB Expert Argues LA’s Postseason Issues Have Not Been on Dave Roberts
The game of baseball can be a weird one. It has it’s ups and downs just like anything else in this world but it’s one of the sports where the best team doesn’t always win the championship each season. Unlike in the NFL or NBA, baseball has a way of invoking chaos come playoff time. It’s both the beauty and the curse of the game, which can be frustrating for the teams involved. For the Dodgers, they know this fact all too well. The team has disappointed come playoff time almost each season despite having a heavy payroll and one of the best rosters in the game.
Many are quick to blame it on manager Dave Roberts and some things are most definitely his fault. But it’s a collective unit that should be given the blame, not just the manager. Baseball writer Andy McCullough of The Athletic feels that the Dodgers’ problems in the playoffs haven’t really all been due to Roberts.
There are reasonable criticisms to be made of Dave Roberts’ managerial stylings. I’ve probably drilled the guy harder in print than any other reporter. There are certainly tactical issues that could be cleaned up, especially in terms of bullpen deployment, in October. But to saddle that all at the feet of the manager, rather than include the front office that crafts the in-game strategy alongside the coaching staff, misses the point. These are organizational failures, rather than individual disasters.
Per The Athletic
Dodger fans demand excellence, it’s just the nature of being a fan of a large market team. So when anything goes wrong in the postseason, someone needs to be blamed. Yes Roberts has made some boneheaded decisions over the course of his Dodger tenure but for the most part, he has put this team into position to win baseball games.
They have made the playoffs every year he has been manager and the team has reached the World Series three times. It’s just an unlucky fact that LA faced off against two teams that were cheating in the Fall Classic otherwise the Roberts-lead Dodgers may have more than the one World Series title right now.
“Could he do some things better? Sure. But the Dodgers could also do a lot worse.”
McCullough, The Athletic
My question to the people who want to get rid of Roberts is who would be better for the job right now? Even if the team did fire Roberts, whoever replaced him would be given direction and a guide to manage the team. That’s just how baseball is played nowadays with all the analytic measures that are available. Decisions are no longer solely on the manager but a combination of the manager and front office.
Putting all the organization letdowns on the manager isn’t fair and Roberts has done a good job during his time with LA. The failures in the playoffs do hurt but baseball playoffs are essentially a crapshoot if you really break it down. The hottest team normally goes on to win the World Series, leaving the dominant teams throughout the year in the dust. We’ve seen it time after time in baseball, unlike any other sport as mentioned above.
Have you subscribed to our YouTube Channel yet? Subscribe and hit that notification bell to stay up to date on all the latest Dodgers news, rumors, interviews, live streams, and more!
He’s right. Dave Roberts has undoubtably made some awful decisions in October but at some point you need to blame the people actually playing the damn game. Every single year (minus 2020) the Dodgers offense flat out disappears in crucial moments.
The 111 win Dodgers somehow had an 0-30 stretch with RISP in the NLDS vs the Padres. The 2017 and 2018 Dodgers hit a combined .200 in the World Series. I’m sorry but that’s not on Dave Roberts. The Dodgers did not lose last years NLDS because of Dave Roberts. They lost it because once again the hitters went MIA and Trea Turner kicked the most routine ground ball you’ve ever seen.
The ONE thing I’ll put on Dave for last year is the concerning lack of energy. The lack of fire. What feels like a lack of desire at times. And it’s leaked over into this season. This team is BORING. If the Dodgers end up with yet another disappointing October outcome, especially if it comes with no energy from the dugout, they need to seriously look at making a change in the dugout. A team having no energy in the Postseason is just absurd. Maybe them missing the Postseason for once wouldn’t be the worst thing in the world. Maybe it would remind them what they’re missing. Because at this point it feels like the entire organization is taking it for granted.
Sorry youir full of it.. It all in on Roberts.. always has been.. go look at his record in big games.. look at the pitchers he has pulled when they are doing great… no guess you you a Roberts fan.. him and Andrew Friedman have to go.. they raise all prices .. and sheap on get the talent…
I agree with Ken, Roberts has been a liability for a long time. He is unable to motivate anybody. This team like all his teams get lazy and complacent. Roberts is a TERRIBLE manager.