What Rob Segedin Tells Us About Running a Sports Franchise

Just moments before Rob Segedin blasted a two-run double off David Price in his historic big league debut, I received a text message saying, “Rob Segdoin, who the f— is that?”. As the Dodgers enter week two of the Rob Segedin era, anybody asking, “who is Rob Segedin?”, has obviously not been paying much attention to the team. In the week since his grand debut, Segedin has collected two more RBI to go along with his .300 batting average. A pretty good career start. In truth, we do not know a ton about the rookie power hitter; however, it is clear that he can smash left-handed pitching, and he seems poised to make a big impact with the club.

In AAA this year, Segedin slugged 21 home runs in 103 games while slashing .319/.392/.598. We also know that Segedin, like Andrew Friedman, is a Tulane University graduate who studies business in his free time. This means that he was probably not out drinking in Des Moines, Iowa after minor league games. Even more interestingly, as the baseball world scrambled to uncover as much information as possible about Segedin this past week, we also learned that he contemplated quitting baseball.

Segedin started in AAA with the Yankees organization last year, putting up steady numbers. However, after 46 games, Rob was suddenly demoted to AA because of what the Yankees called “pure politics”. While Segedin was playing in AAA, there was a prospect named Greg Bird hitting .258 in AA who took Segedin’s place. Bird eventually made it to the majors, but major shoulder surgery has kept him out of action in 2016. Segedin hit .303 after his demotion to AA, and finished out the season back up in AAA.

But for Segedin, his demotion to AA was almost the last straw on his baseball career. “I was ready to quit,” he told NBC about the demotion. Segedin later asked the Yankees for his release, but New York denied it. This left Rob with two options: play in AA or quit baseball. With encouragement from his family, Segedin persevered with the Yankees the rest of the season.

Then the Dodgers came to his rescue.

Would Carlos Gomez Be a Good Fit in Los Angeles?

According to NBC, Andrew Friedman, a fellow Tulane University graduate was always high on Segedin. The Dodgers moved Ronald Torreyes and Tyler Olson to get Segedin who experienced a breakthrough season this year in Oklahoma City.

Segedin’s ascendance to the Major Leagues is well deserved. He was by far the best hitter for Oklahoma City, and the Dodgers, unlike the Yankees do not play “pure politics.” Segedin’s rise to the majors also validates this Dodger front office’s commitment to a system of meritocracy, where only the best performers get to play.

Under this system of merit, Julio Urias not only made his Major League debut, but continues to pitch for the big league club. Likewise, the unheralded Ross Stripling earned his spot in the rotation with a strong spring, and he continues to contribute. Who would have thought that Joe Blanton will be the team’s set up man? When Alex Guerrero refused to go to the minors, the Dodgers simply cut him and ate his contract. More recently, we all know what happened to Yasiel Puig. These shrewd decisions made by the Dodger front office and Manager Dave Roberts are important reasons the team, despite an unprecedented number of injuries and never-ending drama, are legitimate contenders.

On the one hand, the Dodgers system of meritocracy makes perfect sense. The best performing players should get the most playing time. On the other hand, not every sports franchise works in this way. Case and point: the New York Yankees. The favoritism and “pure politics” that the Yankees play is the reason Mark Texeira, batting under .200, hits third on most nights. Yes, the Yankees are paying Texeira $23 million. But the Dodgers are paying Carl Crawford $21 million and owe him an addition $21 million. Look at where he’s at. In the bigger picture, the Yankees’ system of favoritism is the reason that their roster has too many bloated, overpaid, and mediocre but big names.

Favoritism and pure politics is an archaic form of sports management plaguing teams with inept leadership. There is no doubting that George Steinbrenner was one of the best sports owners ever. Hal Steinbrenner is no George. Truthfully, the Dodgers were on the same boat not long ago with Frank and Jamie McCourt. Look at the Lakers after the death of Jerry Buss. Thankfully for the Dodgers, Mark Walter, Magic Johnson, and the rest of the Dodger ownership group knew to hand the keys to Andrew Freidmanand Farhan Zaidi. They, in turn, found diamonds in the rough like Joe Blanton, Ross Stripling, and Rob Segedin to make sure the Dodgers are perennial contenders no matter the circumstance. Thank God, because teams like the Yankees are potentially doomed in this Rob Segedin era of smart baseball.

Dodgers By The Numbers: The Boys in Blue Just Won’t Quit

Sunha Kim

Sunha writes for Dodgers Nation and Boxing Insider. A graduate of The Ohio State University and Harvard, his writing has appeared in Yahoo!, the business news site Quartz, Dodgers Blue Heaven, and Sons of Steve Garvey. A Dodger fan growing up, his favorite player was pinch hitting guru Dave Hansen. Follow him @SunhaPKim. E-mail him at [email protected]


  1. Sunha I agree with your meritocracy comments and how they have helped the Dodgers with fresh young players as others go on the DL. I will say that the flip side of that is they sometimes are so in love with their picks they go with them too long. Hatcher is a great example he should have been shelved a long time before he finally went on the “DL LOL” THe man was a mental basket case.
    Friedman and his team do have loyalties and I applaud that but they are not good at pitching  evaluation they seem to go on their friendships rather than clear heads. Examples are McCarthy, Anderson, Kazmir the Front Office had friendships with these guys and overpaid and in most cases should have never signed them. 
    Other losers were Latos, Johnson, Wood and Avilan. Maeda and Liberatore is are the only decent pitching choice they have made besides Blanton. 
    Say what you want about Colletti but the man and his team was incredible in pitching evaluation. Kershaw, Greinke, Jansen, Urias, DeLeon, Stripling etc. 
    This Front office has stuck us with Maeda, good choice, Kazmir, Anderson, McCarthy, Wood, Latos, Johnson, Hatcher and last but not least Blister Hill…. Blister Hill being the savior we had all anticipated..for some pretty decent prospects in Montas, Holmes and Cotton. And Reddick is burning up the league…..
    To be fair very impressed with pick ups of Coleman, Fein, Segedin, Thompson, Toles and Taylor but wow lots of misses. 
    AND AS pitching is such a huge part of the game I suggest they get Colletti involved in pitching evaluations because these guys are very very bad at it…

  2. But on the flip side, they dumped Greinke at the right time and something has to be said for the resilience of the pitching staff as a while after Kershaw went down.
    Colletti was a fine GM, but let us not forget that he also signed the likes of Andruw Jones and Jason Schmidt.

  3. Sunha Yes but Colletti dealt with one of the worst owners in baseball for many years so in my book he made some deals that he had to as he was restrained from making better ones due to the ownership.
    I will give this Front Office props for working on the Fringes. They are the best Dumpster Divers in the history of baseball I believe. They picked up Fien, Toles Segedin, Liberatore, Taylor,Culberson, Thompson all guys that have or will make large contributions this year or next. .

    But to win you need pitching and so far they are terrible at judging and signing pitching.And Dodger Nation should be very concerned that this Front Office Full of Execs would not know a great pitcher if they ran into them in the Parking Lot…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button